A Child is Rescued in Philadelphia. But Why Was Her Abduction So Easy?

A small child was taken from her classroom by a woman claiming to be her mother. She was found alive the next morning, but police want to know who was able to abduct the child so easily.

  • Share
  • Read Later
AP / Philadelphia Daily News, Alejandro A. Alvarez

Police investigate the playground in Upper Darby, Pa., where a 5-year-old girl wearing only a T-shirt was found hiding under a piece of playground equipment early Tuesday morning.

First the good news: a 5-year-old Philadelphia girl who had gone missing was found alive early Tuesday after being abducted nearly 24 hours earlier from her school. The child was discovered, scared and cold, by a Good Samaritan who heard her cries.

Now the bad news: She was taken by a stranger, dressed in body-covering Muslim-style burqa, who signed her out of her West Philadelphia elementary school Monday morning only giving her name as “Tiffany” and claiming to be the child’s mother.

(MORE: John Walsh on the Etan Patz Case: ‘The Not Knowing Kills You’)

Philadelphia police are trying to piece together how a stranger could walk into a school and take the child. As in many places, school district officials say that anyone picking up a child is required to show identification and be listed as a verified parent or guardian, the Philadelphia Daily News reported. In this case, that policy appears to have been violated. The staff at Bryant Elementary did not discover the girl had been taken until 3 p.m. that day. Surveillance cameras showed her being led off by the stranger on foot. On Monday, the girl’s mother appeared on television explaining that she also wears the traditional Muslim garb.

Police believe that a second woman and a man were also involved in abducting the child, according to the Daily News. Rather than follow instructions to go to the school’s main office, the girl’s abductor went directly to the classroom, which may indicate that she knew where the child would be.

Capt. John Darby of the Philadelphia Police Special Victims Unit told the Daily News that the woman walked into the girl’s classroom and asked for her by name, leading authorities to believe she was targeted. (TIME has opted not to use the child’s name because she is a minor and a possible victim of sexual assault.) “This was not a random act,” he said. Police said she was taken by the woman to a home where there was also an adult male. Her clothes were removed and she was hidden under a bed. An Amber Alert was issued, but cancelled once the girl was found.

The girl was found about 4:40 a.m. Tuesday at a playground in Upper Darby, Pa., by Nelson Mandela Myers, a  sanitation worker headed to work in nearby Norristown who heard her cries and discovered the child near a jungle gym, wearing only a tank top, Upper Darby Police Supt. Michael Chitwood told the Daily News. “She said, ‘I ran away, I ran away from the people who took me.’ ”

Myers, 27, covered the girl with his coat and called 911, he said at a press conference on Tuesday. “I just wanted to do the same thing someone would have done for my child. I have a 5-year-old daughter.

“When I picked her up, she just reminded me of my daughter so much because she was the same size.” He will receive the $10,000 reward offered for her safe return.

It is unclear how the girl escaped her abductors, but other accounts suggest they may have dropped her off at the playground. She was taken to Philadelphia’s Children’s Hospital to be treated for cold weather exposure. There were no apparent signs of injury, but she was being examined for physical and sexual assault. “It had to be an animal to do something like this, to abduct a child and leave her in the park with just a t-shirt,” Chitwood said.

(MORE: Etan Patz: After 33 Years, an Arrest in the Disappearance of the ‘Milk-Carton Boy’)

An investigation is ongoing and Philadelphia police have offered a $10,000 reward for information on the girl’s abduction. Meanwhile her uncle, Sharif Ali, believes her abductor played on her naïveté as a 5-year-old. “I believe that the person told her that she was going to her mother,” he said. “I’m pretty sure [she] knew her. Maybe not her face, but it led her to leave… you’d have to feel comfortable to leave with anybody.”


I don't think the school employee should be persecuted, but I do believe the school should be sued for allowing such a thing. What good is it to have so many policies, if the school, the principal, or whoever is in charge of enforcing those policies doesn't do it? Employees think policies are as important as their boss makes the out to be, so I think it is the administration's fault. I’ve worked at schools, and I remember one case in particular about a boy’s adult sister, wanting to take him out for early release but her name was not on the boy’s record. So we didn’t let that boy go no matter how much he told us she was his sister and that they lived in the same house. Did we upset a lot of people? Yes! But we were not going to risk getting our jobs in the line, or have the school involved in such a mess.  


The school f***** up beyond belief.   They need to IMMEDIATELY fire whoever signed the child out,  name that employee publicly   and  file criminal charges against said employee for endangering the life of the child.     However,  this is unlikely  due to Union protection of said employee.   This shameful excuse for a person will likely be protected by the union, and have virtually no consequences whatsoever.


Very strange story. The woman who abducted her is most likely not Muslim but knew that the real mother covered head to toe in a burqa. Why were the girl's clothing removed? Was she raped? Was she photographed?

My wild theory is that it is someone who wanted to scare the family for another purpose. It could be to force cooperation on an illicit activity or a government effort to coerce them to become snitches on other Muslims.