If It Ain’t Broke: 5 ‘Girl Meets World’ Characters Who Resemble Their Predecessors

Now that the protagonist and BFF have been cast for the Boy Meets World spinoff, what other archetypes should we expect to see in 'Girl Meets World'? Plus the latest on which characters from the original series might be returning.

  • Share
  • Read Later
David Livingston / Getty Images

Actress Sabrina Carpenter has been tapped to play the role of 'Maya Fox' on Girl Meets World, the upcoming Boy Meets World spinoff.

In the wake of Monday’s casting news regarding Riley Matthews, the protagonist of the coming sequel to the much-beloved (at least by us) 90s sitcom Boy Meets World, more revelations about the series have been coming fast and furious. Last night, Entertainment Weekly reported that the role of Maya Fox, Riley’s best friend, had been cast as well. Also, it was reported that producers have leaked details about three other supporting characters: older brother Elliott Mathews and likely classmates Tristan Friar and Shamus Farkle.

First off, those are some fantastic names—clearly something for which creator Michael Jacobs has an uncanny knack (see also: Lawrence, Topanga and Minkus, Stuart). Secondly, the descriptions of these characters seem rather… familiar. In fact, there’s plenty of direct parallels between these new seventh-graders and their Boy Meets World predecessors.

Riley Matthews = Cory Mathews (“The Main Character”)

Both characters shoulder the lion’s share of world-meeting on their respective shows. (We broke down the potential paths for young Riley earlier this week.)

Maya Fox = Shawn Hunter (“The Best Friend”)

From Maya Fox’s character description, according to Vulture:

“Maya is an only child and has never known her father, which makes her relationship with both Riley and Cory Matthews very important to her. She is a wonderful student of life and absolutely magnetic in attracting the people in her sphere. A little bit edgy, she is as fiercely loyal to Riley as Riley is to her.”

Shawn Hunter (Rider Strong) began Boy Meets World as an only child (before discovering he had a long-lost half-brother in his senior year of high school). He also had a notoriously complicated relationship with his father, which is why Cory and his parents quickly became Shawn’s surrogate family. And the other characteristics ascribed to Maya closely mirror Shawn’s: “wonderful student of life” (21st-century Disney-speak for “street-smart”), popular, rebellious and loyal.

In fact, it would actually be surprising if Maya didn’t turn out to be Shawn’s daughter at some point during the series’ run—a revelation made more likely by the fact that Jacobs recently stated that Strong would likely be part of the spinoff.

Elliot Matthews = Eric Matthews (“The Brother”)

From Elliot Matthews’ character description, via Entertainment Weekly:

Cory and Topanga’s son. This guy will start the series as a “thinking man’s jock.” He’s described as “good looking, well built, funny and insightful in his observations. Good hearted except for his dedication toward using Riley (Blanchard) as his wrestling practice dummy. His parents worry that he has inherited the ‘Eric Matthews Algernon’ gene and will lose intelligence as time goes by.” That “Eric Matthews Algernon” bit is a two-part reference to a character in the original series who got dumber as seasons passed and the classic novel with a similar theme, Flowers for Algernon.

“Good looking, well built, funny and insightful” pretty much hits the nail on the head for the Eric Matthews (Will Friedle) from BMW‘s first few seasons (though you’d be remiss not too mention “a phenomenal head of hair“). Though Eric wasn’t a jock, he was certainly portrayed as popular, so that should like up pretty well. Also, the fact that they’re already discussing the ‘Eric Matthews Algernon’ gene for Elliot is fantastic and that particular turn of phrase should certainly be employed on GMW. Frequently.

Tristan Friar = Topanga Lawrence (“The Unexpected Love Interest”)

From Tristan Friar’s character description, via EW:

 An Austin, Texas transplant who’s a “cowboy in the city.” His description: “He seems actually possessed of ethics, common sense and a value system making him immediately alien to everybody else except Riley, who believes it’s the value system that attracts her to want to be his friend even though he’s too good looking for her to look at.”

Austin may be a little far away from Philly (the setting for BMW and, presumably, GMW), but the principle is the same: Tristan is an outsider because he’s a “cowboy;” Topanga (Danielle Fishel), a recent transplant from Pittsburgh, was an outsider because of her over-the-top spirituality. In fact, Cory was fond of calling Topanga an actual alien—though it seems the producers have decided to make Riley somewhat more tolerant than her father/predecessor. Throughout high school, Topanga was consistently out of Cory’s league, especially in the looks department, but that seemed to work out for both parties in the end.

Shamus Farkle = Stuart Minkus (“The Nerd Nemesis”)

Via EW:

This is the show’s resident genius. “Future world ruler. Riley’s rebellious best friend Maya is his nemesis, Riley gets between them to save his life. Farkle is wildly attached and protective of both girls and loves equally that Riley doesn’t make him miserable and Maya does.” (EW)

This may be the biggest departure from BMW‘s initial archetype. “Future world leader” and “nemesis” absolutely scream Stuart Minkus, but the fact that Shamus is close with Riley and actually cares for both her and Maya distinguishes him from Minkus. In the first season of BMW, Cory and Shawn tormented Minkus (and Topanga) relentlessly, but this particular love-hate relationship triangle seems to be based more on the former than the latter. Plus the description of the Maya-Shamus relationship seems primed for sparks somewhere down the line, perhaps when GMW hits the high school years (assuming, of course, Shamus doesn’t disappear after just one season like Minkus did).

The other major development of the week came in show creator Jacobs’ interview with the Hollywood Reporter, where he revealed that Friedle said, “I will be at every taping.” Let’s all hope that means in front of the camera, and ideally in every single scene. It’s important to never forget that Eric Matthews is the best.

5 comments
BrianRommel
BrianRommel

Elliot's been nixed in favor of a younger brother named Auggie so perhaps a Morgan expy?

BrianRommel
BrianRommel

The whole shawn is Maya's father is an interesting idea but assumes he an Angela didn't work out as well as hoped either they didn't stay together or he wasn't faithful which would throw out his character development. Its worth noting that Fox and Hunter go together though recent reports list Mays's surname now as Hart, not Fox. 

Stacey4579
Stacey4579

Shawn actually started the series with a sister named Stacey. She was the one that gave Shawn the perm to help Cory straighten his hair in one of the earlier episodes.

Anywho, GMW is starting to sound awesome. I just really wish it wasn't on the Disney Channel where the storylines will be incredibly restricted.

Kyle_Gmcube
Kyle_Gmcube

Girl Meets World has been said to take place in New York, not Philly.  That's where they moved in the series finale.

BrianRommel
BrianRommel

@Stacey4579  That was main lt do to production firing the second friend of the week (the original plan was that Cory had two friends but they hadn't settled on anyone by the time the series got picked up this is why Cory and Shawn seem to always have different friends depending on the episode. This episode was supposed to have one but the kid just wasn't working for that episode so he was fired and his lines were given to Shawn including the sister stacey. Shawn also had another Half brother that was never brought up again either. Heck Topanga had a sister named Nebula in one episode that was never mentioned again.

As for the episodes on Disney Channel all but a few were barred from airing on disney channel in syndication I know of two both season 5 episodes.