Man Afraid Of Frogs Awarded $1.6 Million Verdict

A man in upstate New York was recently awarded $1.6 million in damages after a developer inadvertently caused frogs to swarm on his land.

  • Share
  • Read Later
Amy Lombard for TIME

Frogs at the New York Reptile Expo

A man in upstate New York with a very particular phobia was recently awarded $1.6 million in damages after a developer inadvertently caused  his land to be inundated by frogs.

Paul Marinaccio, 65, of Clarence, N.Y. was deluged with frogs on his property after construction at a nearby real estate project sent  the little critters hopping onto his land.

(MORE: Save the Frogs: California High School Bans Dissections)

In 2000, a developer began diverting water runoff towards Marinaccio’s  home, essentially turning much of his  property into a wetland. As a result, the frogs soon came flocking. Marinaccio’s phobia seems to stem from his childhood, as the Buffalo News reports:

[Marinaccio] traces his deep-seated fear of frogs to when he was a child in an Italian vineyard, where his parents worked. He remembers wandering to a nearby property for figs and being chased away by a man holding bullfrogs.

Apparently, that was enough to make an indelible impression. He claims he’s resorted to desperate measures in an attempt to avoid the amphibians that congregate on his land. He once even accompanied a town official to show him his home – by bulldozer.

(MORE: Cowboy Frogs and Crayola Crickets: 46 New Species Found in Suriname)

In 2006, Marinaccio decided to sue the city for his ordeal. He told the court that at times, he cannot enter his own home because there are frogs in front of the door. In times of desperate need, he calls his daughter to come over so she can shoo the  creatures away. Marinaccio, who runs a construction company, reportedly once paid a worker $65 to catch the frogs so that he could get out of his house.

“In the winter, it’s OK, because I know there’s no frogs,” Marinaccio said. “But in the summertime, I mean, I’m a damn prisoner in my own home.”


I don't blame that man I understand his fear.. I am terrified of frogs snakes and lizards. So I can just imagine his horror of seeing all those damn frogs hoping around your door and u can't even leave your house!


How about instead of the BS title you could run an article about how the developer turned this mans land into a freaking swamp.


I have a terrible fear of rats and mice, stemming from childhood days in the Midwest in the 1970s. How come I don't get a million dollars.


This case smells fishy...or swampy :P

1. I should like to see some evidence that this man's phobia predated the amphibian invasion.

2. Unless the frogs did 1.6 million dollars in damage, the award makes *no* sense at all.